Whole-house and gut renovations on Cape Cod
A gut renovation takes an older Cape house back to the studs and rebuilds it: new layout, systems, insulation and finishes. On Cape Cod, four things can reshape the plan, so check them before design: flood zone, historic district, lead and asbestos, and septic. A large gut can also bring the whole house under the stretch energy code.
What counts as a "major" or "gut" renovation?
- The Massachusetts building code sorts work on an existing house into three levels.
- Level 3 is any alteration where the work area is more than 50% of the house. Most gut renovations land here.
- The higher the level, the more of the current code the work must meet.
More about what counts as a "major" or "gut" renovation
Massachusetts' building code (780 CMR, 10th edition) is based on the 2021 International Existing Building Code, with state amendments. That model code splits alterations into levels:
- Level 1: replacing or covering existing materials with new ones that do the same job. New flooring, new cabinets in the same spot.
- Level 2: adding or removing a door or window, reconfiguring or extending a system, or adding equipment, where the work area is 50% of the building or less.
- Level 3: the same kind of work, but where "the work area exceeds 50 percent of the building area."
"Work area" is the part of the house actually being reconfigured, not the whole footprint. A kitchen, a bath and a couple of bedrooms in a small house can cross the line. A whole-house gut always does.
Why it matters: the level decides which code rules apply. Your building department makes the call, so we sort out the classification with them before the plans are final, not after.
Our Yarmouth Port project is a good example. As the project page puts it: "a full gut, level 3 alteration. That means everything comes out and gets rebuilt the right way from the ground up."
How much does a gut renovation cost on Cape Cod?
- National published figure: $130–$200 per sq ft, or $260,000–$400,000 for a 2,000 sq ft house (Block Renovation, June 24, 2026). We haven't found a published Cape-only figure.
- Hold 10–20% for surprises, and lean toward the high end for older homes (same source). On a gut, that money is part of the plan, because opening walls is how you find out what the house needs.
- We don't publish our own prices. Your number comes from a site visit and a written proposal.
More about how much does a gut renovation cost on Cape Cod
- Block Renovation, a national renovation company, says older and historic homes "are the hardest to price up front" because of unknown conditions, lead and asbestos testing and custom work (June 24, 2026).
- Angi's guide to gutting a house says demolition is likely to reveal "issues like lead paint and rotting wood once you get down to the studs," and advises a contingency budget "if your home is of significant age" (updated Sep 28, 2026).
- How we handle it: we price what we can see, name the things we can't see yet (sills, wiring, what's under the old flooring), and agree with you up front how changes are approved once the walls are open.
Full published ranges for gut renovations, baths and additions are in our Cape Cod renovation cost guide.
Ready to talk about your house? Send the address and what you want to change.
What does the code require when you gut a house?
- Energy, small or medium guts: the parts you rebuild must meet today's energy code for new work.
- Energy, big guts: every Cape town uses the Massachusetts stretch energy code (as of November 2026). Under it, a major renovation over 1,000 sq ft, or over 100% of the heated floor area, can require the whole house to hit a maximum HERS score. A HERS score is an energy rating from a certified rater; lower means more efficient.
- Smoke and CO alarms: when permitted work happens, the house gets smoke and carbon monoxide alarms placed as required for a new home.
More about what does the code require when you gut a house
- The model rule. The national model code says Level 3 alterations are allowed "without requiring the entire building or structure to comply with the energy requirements," but the altered work itself has to meet the energy code (IEBC 2021 §907.1). In a gut, that's most of the house: new insulation in opened walls and roofs, air sealing, windows.
- The Massachusetts stretch code goes further. Section R503.1.5 of the 2025 stretch and specialized code (225 CMR 22.00) says that for one- and two-family homes, an alteration that meets the code's definition of an "Extensive Alteration" and exceeds 1,000 sq ft or 100% of the existing conditioned floor area must bring the dwelling to the maximum HERS ratings in Table R406.5. Those maximums are 65 for a house that burns gas, oil or propane, 70 for an all-electric house or one with solar, and 75 for an all-electric house with solar. Historic buildings may follow a different path. Whether your gut counts as an "Extensive Alteration" is your building department's call, so ask early. It changes the insulation, air-sealing and heating plan, and the budget.
- Which energy code. As of October 27, 2026, the state's adoption list shows all 15 Cape towns on the stretch code, and Eastham, Truro and Wellfleet also on the stricter specialized code. Confirm your town with the building department. The state proposed revisions to both codes in 2026 (comments closed June 24, 2026). As of November 14, 2026, the state's page still lists the February 14, 2025 version as the latest.
- Smoke and CO alarms. Under the model residential code, "where alterations, repairs or additions requiring a permit occur," the home must get smoke alarms and carbon monoxide alarms "located as required for new dwellings." Exterior-only work like roofing, siding or windows is an exception. Massachusetts has its own amendments, so confirm with your building official.
- Additions on top of a gut. If the job also adds space, the addition has its own energy rules (the same 1,000 sq ft / 100% trigger). See Home additions.
What's hiding behind the walls of an older Cape house?
- Lead paint in homes built before 1978, with real legal rules for both you and your contractor.
- Asbestos in old siding, flooring, heating insulation, joint compound and more. It needs state notice before removal.
- Knob-and-tube wiring in many pre-1950 houses.
- Rotted sills and framing, which you can't see until the walls and floors are open.
More about what's hiding behind the walls of an older Cape house
Lead paint (homes built before 1978)
- Massachusetts' Lead Law "requires the removal or covering of lead paint hazards in homes built before 1978 where any children under 6 live." It applies to "owners living in their own single family home," not just landlords.
- Separately, renovation done for a fee in pre-1978 housing that disturbs more than 6 sq ft of painted surface per room inside, or more than 20 sq ft outside, must be done by a licensed lead-safe renovation contractor, with a certified supervisor on site whenever work is in progress (Mass. Department of Labor Standards). A gut renovation clears those thresholds on day one.
Asbestos
- MassDEP says asbestos can turn up in "decorative plasters, fireproofing, resilient flooring, heating system insulation, wallboard joint compound systems, mastics, roofing, exterior siding, and more."
- Anyone planning asbestos removal has to notify MassDEP and the Department of Labor Standards at least 10 working days before work starts. Your town's board of health, building inspector and fire department may have their own requirements.
- MassDEP's own advice: if the material is in good condition, "the best thing you can do is leave it alone." In a gut, that's often not possible, so we test before demolition, not during it.
Old wiring
- HomeGuide notes that pre-1950 homes "typically have knob and tube wiring, which does not meet current safety standards." It puts replacement at $12,000–$35,000 nationally (Aug 29, 2025), usually with a panel upgrade. When the walls are open is the time to do it.
Sills and framing
- Sill plates sit right on the foundation, and damage there usually stays hidden until the walls and floors are open. HomeGuide puts sill replacement at $120–$200 per linear foot, or $12,000–$35,000 nationally (Sep 20, 2025).
These are national figures from a cost publisher, not Guild pricing. Local costs can differ. See the cost guide.
Will a gut renovation force me to raise my house? (FEMA's 50% rule)
- If your home is in a FEMA flood zone and the work costs 50% or more of the building's market value, it's a "substantial improvement."
- The house then generally has to be brought up to current floodplain rules, which can mean raising it. Your building department makes the call.
- A gut renovation can cross that line easily. We check it before design, not after.
More about will a gut renovation force me to raise my house
- The rule. FEMA defines substantial improvement as any reconstruction, rehabilitation, addition or other improvement "the cost of which equals or exceeds 50 percent of the market value of the structure" before construction starts (44 CFR 59.1).
- What happens if you cross it. The building generally has to be brought into compliance as if it were new construction. FEMA's training material notes that for an addition, "if the common wall is demolished as part of the project, then the entire structure must be elevated."
- What counts. FEMA counts materials, labor, built-in appliances, overhead and profit. Plans, surveys and permit fees don't count. Market value is the building only, not the land.
- Some towns count over time. FEMA notes some communities add up all improvements over five years, 10 years or the life of the building. Ask your town's floodplain or building office how yours does it.
- Historic homes. The federal definition excludes alterations of a "historic structure" as long as the work doesn't stop it from keeping that designation (44 CFR 59.1). Whether your house qualifies is a question for the town.
- Code-violation fixes. Work the code official has identified as needed to correct existing health, sanitary or safety violations, and that is "the minimum necessary to assure safe living conditions," is also excluded.
What to do: find your flood zone and get a realistic market value for the building before design. If you're close to 50%, the scope can sometimes be phased or reshaped. That's a conversation for the start of a project, not the middle.
Is your house in the Old King's Highway Historic District?
- The Old King's Highway Regional Historic District covers the area north of Route 6 (the Mid-Cape Highway) from Sandwich to Orleans.
- Six towns each have their own committee: Sandwich, Barnstable, Yarmouth, Dennis, Brewster and Orleans.
- Exterior changes, new construction and demolition need the committee's approval before you build.
More about is your house in the Old King's Highway Historic District
- Where it is. Barnstable describes the district as "the area north of Route 6 (the Mid Cape Highway) from Sandwich to Orleans," created in 1973, with each town running its own committee. The regional commission lists committees in Sandwich, Barnstable, Yarmouth, Dennis, Brewster and Orleans. That generally takes in villages such as Sandwich village, West Barnstable, Barnstable Village, Cummaquid, Yarmouth Port, Dennis, Brewster and Orleans north of Route 6. Confirm your address with the town.
- What they review. Barnstable's committee reviews "any change in the exterior of buildings and structures, fences and signs," plus new construction and demolition. It looks at design, proportion, texture, materials, color, setting and the relative size of buildings. Yarmouth lists signs, paint, solar panels, additions, fences and sheds, and requires a public hearing for a Certificate of Appropriateness.
- Work you can't see from the road. In Yarmouth, projects not visible from a public way may ask for a Certificate of Exemption, which doesn't need a hearing.
- Interior work. The town pages we read describe exterior review. A gut that's interior-only may not need a certificate, but new windows, siding, trim, roofing or a changed roofline usually means a review. Confirm with your town committee before you order materials.
- Timing. The regional commission's procedures say a town committee has 45 days to act on an application unless the applicant agrees in writing to an extension. Confirm current timing with your town. Build the hearing into the schedule, because it can be the longest wait in a Route 6A project.
- Outside the district. Other towns and villages can have their own local historic or demolition-review rules. We check with the town before we design.
Can I get a Mass Save heat pump rebate during a gut?
- A gut is the best time to replace an oil or propane system. The ductwork and wiring are already open.
- Mass Save's 2026 whole-home heat pump rebate is $2,650 per ton, up to $8,500. For projects installed on or after January 1, 2027, it drops to $2,350 per ton, capped at $7,500.
- The whole-home and partial-home rebates are only for homes occupied full time during the winter heating season. Many Cape second homes won't qualify.
More about can I get a Mass Save heat pump rebate during a gut
- Whole-home vs. partial. Mass Save lists a partial-home rebate as well, with its own rules about keeping or removing the old system. Ask us which fits your house.
- Income-eligible homes. Mass Save lists income-based enhanced incentives of "up to $16,000 or up to no cost through Turnkey Services" for income-qualified households.
- Who to talk to. On the Cape, Cape Light Compact runs the energy efficiency programs "instead of the local electric utility." Confirm your eligibility with them before you count the rebate in your budget.
- Summer house? If the house isn't lived in full time through the winter, plan the budget without the whole-home or partial-home rebate. Mass Save's smaller Basic rebate ($250 per ton, up to $2,500) is for heat pumps that don't replace your existing fossil-fuel or electric-resistance heat, and Mass Save lists "a home that is not occupied in the winter (e.g., summer home)" as one example. Confirm with Cape Light Compact before you count on it. See Second-home owners.
How does a gut renovation work with Guild Design Build?
One team designs and builds. We look at the things that can stop or reshape a project first, then design, then build.
- Walk-through: the house, the site, what you want.
- Rule check: flood zone and the 50% line, historic district, septic and bedroom count, lead and asbestos testing.
- Design and written proposal: with clear allowances for what we can't see yet.
- Permits and approvals: building permit, historic committee where it applies.
- Build: demolition, structure, systems roughed in before anything is closed up, then finishes.
More about how does a gut renovation work with Guild Design Build
- Why septic is on the list. Adding bedrooms in a gut changes what your septic system has to handle. See Septic, Title 5 and adding space before you plan an extra bedroom.
- Why design-build. You're not handing plans from one firm to another and paying for the gaps. See How design-build works.
- What "built right" looks like on our jobs. On the Yarmouth Port gut, the crew sheathed the whole house in ZIP System panels (a structural panel with a built-in water-resistive barrier), ran Vycor ice and water shield along the base of the walls, and installed James Hardie fiber-cement board-and-batten siding. Next on that job: roughing in the electrical, plumbing and HVAC, done before anything is closed up. The project is still in progress.
- Experience. Rick Conway has 29 years in the trades: 24 years running crews and jobs for other builders, and the last 5 owning Cape Cod Carpentry Guild Inc.
What gut and restoration work have we done on the Cape?
- Yarmouth Port: full gut, Level 3 alteration (in progress).
- Mashpee: foundation and exterior repair after a car crash.
- North Falmouth: restoring a 1940s porch built for coastal weather.
More about what gut and restoration work have we done on the Cape
- Full gut in Yarmouth Port. "A tired, dated structure that had run its course," taken back and rebuilt as a Level 3 alteration. ZIP System sheathing, Vycor at the base of the walls, James Hardie board and batten, with rough electrical, plumbing and HVAC next. Still in progress. See the project (opens in a new tab)
- Foundation repair in Mashpee. A car crash damaged a home's foundation. The crew excavated, cut concrete and installed several steel beams to support the structure, and helped the homeowner through the insurance process. Foundation repair (opens in a new tab)
- Mashpee restoration. A Mashpee home damaged in a car collision got its exterior restored with new white cedar shingles, and the crew rebuilt the foundation and siding "despite setbacks with insurance and engineering." Repair nears completion (opens in a new tab) · Restoration complete (opens in a new tab)
- 1940s charm in North Falmouth. Restoring the structure of a 1940s porch while keeping its vintage look, built to the codes that deal with "salty breezes, high winds, and flood challenges." See the project (opens in a new tab)
More older-home work: Fireplace makeover in Yarmouth Port (opens in a new tab) · Windows and PVC trim in Marstons Mills (opens in a new tab) · Exterior work in Marstons Mills (opens in a new tab). See all projects.
Ready to plan your renovation?
Tell us the address and what you're thinking. We start with the flood zone, the historic district, the septic and the energy code, so the plan starts on solid ground. Request a proposal Guild Design Build, a brand of Cape Cod Carpentry Guild Inc. · MA HIC #210736 · Based in Pocasset · About Rick Conway and the team · What homeowners say
More about ready to plan your renovation
- What happens after you send it: we read what you sent and contact you to talk it through. We'll get back to you as soon as we can. We're working hard on every client's project, and we'll be in touch soon. If it looks like a fit, we set up a free walk-through of the house (or we can start with a video walkthrough of your home.). Next comes the design phase, with a design fee based on the size of the project, then plans, a hard quote from subcontractor bids, and a detailed proposal.
- Helpful to have ready: the address, roughly when the house was built, any old plans or past permits, septic records if you have them, and photos of the rooms you want to change.
- Not ready yet? Read how design-build works or the Cape Cod renovation cost guide first.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a gut renovation cost on Cape Cod?
National published figures put a full gut at $130–$200 per sq ft, or $260,000–$400,000 for 2,000 sq ft (Block Renovation, Jun 2026). Local costs can differ.
More about this answer: How much does a gut renovation cost on Cape Cod?
We don't publish our own prices, and we haven't found a published Cape-specific figure. Older houses cost more to price because of what's behind the walls. Hold 10–20% for contingency. Our cost guide has the full published ranges. Your real number comes from a site visit and a written proposal.
What is a Level 3 alteration?
It's the building code's name for an alteration where the work area is more than 50% of the house. Most whole-house guts are Level 3.
More about this answer: What is a Level 3 alteration?
Massachusetts' building code is based on the 2021 International Existing Building Code. Level 3 work brings more of the current code into play, including energy rules for the rebuilt areas. Your building department confirms the level.
Will a gut renovation force me to raise my house?
Only if the house is in a FEMA flood zone and the work costs 50% or more of the building's market value. Then it's a "substantial improvement" and the house must meet current flood rules, which can include elevation.
More about this answer: Will a gut renovation force me to raise my house?
Market value is the building only, not the land. Plans, surveys and permits don't count toward the cost. Some towns add up improvements over several years. Historic structures can be excluded. Check before design.
Do I have to bring the whole house up to the energy code?
Sometimes. As of November 2026, every Cape town uses the Massachusetts stretch energy code, and under it a large "extensive alteration" (over 1,000 sq ft, or over 100% of the heated floor area) must bring the whole house to a maximum HERS energy score.
More about this answer: Do I have to bring the whole house up to the energy code?
The maximum is 65 for a house that burns gas, oil or propane, 70 for an all-electric or solar house, and 75 for an all-electric house with solar (225 CMR 22.00, R503.1.5 and Table R406.5). Smaller alterations only need the rebuilt parts to meet the code for new work. Eastham, Truro and Wellfleet are also on the stricter specialized code (state list as of Oct 27, 2026). Your building department decides which rule applies.
Do I need historic district approval to renovate in Yarmouth Port or Barnstable Village?
If the house is north of Route 6 in Sandwich, Barnstable, Yarmouth, Dennis, Brewster or Orleans, exterior changes need approval from the town's Old King's Highway committee.
More about this answer: Do I need historic district approval to renovate in Yarmouth Port or Barnstable Village?
Committees review exterior changes, new construction and demolition: siding, windows, roofing, paint, additions, fences, solar. In Yarmouth, work not visible from a public way may qualify for a Certificate of Exemption without a hearing. Confirm interior-only work with your town committee.
My house was built before 1978. What about lead paint?
Assume there's lead paint until it's tested. Renovation for a fee that disturbs more than 6 sq ft per room inside, or 20 sq ft outside, must be done by a licensed lead-safe renovation contractor.
More about this answer: My house was built before 1978. What about lead paint?
If a child under 6 lives in the home, the Massachusetts Lead Law requires lead hazards to be removed or covered, including in an owner-occupied single-family home. That needs a licensed lead inspector, and deleading by a trained, licensed person.
Can I get the Mass Save heat pump rebate on a summer house?
Not the whole-home or partial-home rebate. Mass Save says both are "only available to residences that are occupied full time during the winter heating season."
More about this answer: Can I get the Mass Save heat pump rebate on a summer house?
For full-time homes, the 2026 whole-home rebate is $2,650 per ton up to $8,500, dropping to $2,350 per ton capped at $7,500 for installs on or after Jan 1, 2027. Mass Save lists a summer home as one example for its smaller Basic rebate ($250 per ton, up to $2,500). Confirm eligibility with Cape Light Compact.